Single post
  • Business Hours : 24 Hours

  • (845) 625-2050

  • info@mmtires.com

Where should you buy tires in Nanuet

Whatever make or model you drive, and whether it’s a truck, car, SUV, minivan, or commercial vehicle, you’re riding on tires. (If you aren’t, you have a more serious problem). Your tires are the only parts on your vehicle that make contact with the road. They’re the most important safety component on your vehicle – without traction, you’re slip-sliding around snow-covered roads in Spring Valley or understeering on the cloverleaf at the Palisades Parkway.

Your tires need to be replaced eventually. If it’s not because they’re worn out, it’s because the rubber starts to deteriorate and crack after just a few years. Before you know it, you’ll need to put new tires on your vehicle.

When you start your search for tires in Nanuet, NY, your browser is going to be flooded with results. Everyone and their mother advertises discount tires in Nanuet or brags that they are the best, most professional tire shop in the state of New York. Let’s be honest, here. What you really care about is that your tire purchase is a fair price and as convenient as possible. Is that too much to ask?

The usual culprits on a Google search for tire sales or tire repairs in Rockland NY and the surrounding areas are Costco Tire Center, Mavis Discount Tire, Midas Muffler, and Sears Auto Center. If you’re thinking STS tires should be on that list too, you’d be right…except they’re part of Mavis Tire now.

There’s just one name – a very important one – that you’ll want to keep in mind: MM Tires
So, let’s take a look at these tire stores in Rockland County, pitting them head-to-head. And at the end, discover who comes out on top.

Compare tire shops in nanuet

  • Companies
  • Mobile tire services
  • Brands/Availability
  • Pricing
  • Customer satisfaction
  • Wheel Alignment
  • Mavis
  • No
  • Good
  • Average
  • Good
  • Yes
  • Costco
  • No
  • Poor
  • Excellent
  • Meh
  • No
  • Midas
  • No
  • Who knows?
  • No clue
  • Good
  • Yes
  • Sears
  • No
  • Good
  • Good
  • Decent
  • Yes
  • MM Tires
  • Yes
  • Excellent
  • Excellent
  • Top Rated
  • No

Top Places to Buy Tires in Nanuet, NY

Name
Reviews
Number of Reviews
Overall Star Ratings
Address
Phone Number
Website
Mavis Discount Tires
average service
32 reviews
3.0 stars
81 Smith St, Nanuet, NY 10954
(845) 623-7573
mavistire.com
Mavis Discount Tires
below average service
14 reviews
2.5 stars
321 NY-59, Nanuet, NY 10954
(845) 443-8005
mavistire.com
Costco Tire Center
good service, poor selection
113 reviews
4.2 stars
50 Overlook Blvd, Nanuet, NY 10954
(845) 425-1469
costco.com
Midas Muffler
lack of knowledge, friendly service
30 reviews
2.7 stars
215 West Route 59, Nanuet, NY 10954
(845) 623-2050
midas.com
Sears Auto Center
very poor
33 reviews
1.8 stars
100 W Rte 59, Nanuet, NY 10954
(845) 627-4581
searsauto.com
MM Tires
top-rated convenience, excellent selection
95 reviews
5.0 stars
Spring Valley, NY (MOBILE)
(845) 625-2050
mmtires.com
  • Services
  • Mobile tire services
  • Brands/Availability
  • Pricing
  • Customer satisfaction
  • Wheel Alignment
  • Mavis
  • No
  • Good
  • Average
  • Good
  • Yes
  • Costco
  • No
  • Poor
  • Excellent
  • Meh
  • No
  • Midas
  • No
  • Who knows?
  • No clue
  • Good
  • Yes
  • Sears
  • No
  • Good
  • Good
  • Decent
  • Yes
  • MM Tires
  • Yes
  • Excellent
  • Excellent
  • Top Rated
  • No

MM Tires

You want a tire specialist, and with MM Tires, you’ve got it. MM Tires in Rockland NY is a mobile tire shop that caters to tire customers only! You’re not going to find a shop that wants to sell you brakes and shocks just because they’re taking your tires off. They’re going to do their job and do it well, because tires are all they do.

MM Tires stands out in a few categories. The first is their hours of operation. MM Tires is a 24-hour company that works for you when YOU are available, so they are definitely the best in convenience. The second is their facility, or lack thereof. MM Tires comes to you at your home, office, or elsewhere. You don’t have to take off work a couple hours early just because you need new tires or need a tire repaired. Third, their tire availability is second to none. Whatever tire brand, model, or size you need, they’ll get it and bring it to you. As long as local warehouses have them in stock, MM Tires will supply and install them for you the same day.

When you call MM Tires, they will be at your location in under an hour. That’s something you can’t say for Mavis, Midas, Costco, or Sears. And if you need tires for your fleet vehicle or your commercial van, that’s not a problem either. As if that’s not enough, their online reviews indicate you’re going to be satisfied: they have a perfect 5.0 stars out of 5.

The choice is clear: MM Tires is undoubtedly the best choice to buy new tires in Nanuet NY. They have the most convenient service, specialized tire abilities, and fast, friendly service. The only thing MM Tires doesn’t have is that awful waiting room coffee.

Bottom line

The choice is clear: MM Tires is undoubtedly the best choice to buy new tires in Nanuet NY. They have the most convenient service, specialized tire abilities, and fast, friendly service. The only thing MM Tires doesn’t have is that awful waiting room coffee.

Midas Muffler

There might be a small issue if you’re trusting a muffler shop for your tire sales in Rockland. Really, why would you expect that a shop that made its name on exhaust repairs would be your best choice? Customer experience is a huge motivating factor when it comes to repair facilities in today’s marketplace, and that’s where Midas Muffler excels. Yet the benefit of a tire specialist shop should be apparent.

Midas Muffler also lacks in convenience. They aren’t open any evenings; their hours of operation are Monday to Friday from 7:30 to 6, Saturday from 7:30 to 5, and Sunday from 8 to 4. They have four location in Rockland County, so I guess there’s that.

You can’t get pricing online for your tires or tire services either. You have to call the store or email for a quote. And frankly, who has time for that? When you’re there, you can expect had upsells too, from engine services and brakes to their $49.99 wheel alignment special.

Bottom line

Good customer service, below average convenience, and few details available online.

Costco Tire Center

Few tire retailers have tire warranty included with their tire sales. Costco is one of the select few that includes road hazard tire warranty with every tire you buy. They also include tire rotations, balancing and flat tire repairs for the life of your tires – a money-saving benefit for sure. Installation and balancing is extremely reasonable at $14 per tire too…but that’s right around where the benefits end.

Costco is always busy. You’re just a membership number there, and they’ll churn the work out for you quickly but without a personal touch. You can’t get a wheel alignment at the Costco Tire Center, so if you need one, you’ll have to make another appointment elsewhere. They only work on passenger vehicles, so forget installing new hoops on your five-ton truck there. And if you can’t get there between 9 and 5, you’re not getting your tires installed.

One other major issue: availability. If you have a problem with your tire that can’t be fixed, it’s replaced for you under warranty. However, chances are slim that Costco will still have your tire available in their warehouses. That means you’ll be on the hook for the remainder of the mismatched tires, should you want to do it right.

Bottom line

Great pricing, impersonal service, poor availability

Sears Auto Center

When you’re having your new tires installed, don’t you want to shop for new trousers and underwear? Maybe small appliances too? That’s what you’ll get at Sears Auto Center – a one-stop shop for all your automotive and clothing needs.

For in-store convenience, Sears might be the best option. Their hours are Monday thru Saturday from 7:30 to 7 and Sunday from 9 to 5. The tire pricing is pretty competitive and they have online specials running all the time, it seems. And you truly can get all your vehicle maintenance completed in one location. From wheel alignments and free battery inspections to brake repairs and more, Sears can do it all. But do you want Sears doing all that to your car?

You have service options at Sears including a Standard, Silver, and Gold package. The Gold package even includes lifetime wheel alignments, but the pricing is missing online. Maybe it’s a costly option…

Bottom Line

Sears is an all-in-one auto service shop, but expect upsells and potentially higher costs.

Mavis Discount Tires

You know the name because there are four Mavis Tire centers in the Rockland area. They’re good at what they do, and their Google ratings are 4.6 stars. Their customer reviews say they are friendly and convenient and they advertise that they sell all the top tire brands. You’ll even find coupons online, and they promise to beat any price from competitors.

What you’ll find is that Mavis is convenient…when they are open. Store hours during the week are 8 am to 6 pm, open late on Thursdays until 8:30 pm. Weekends they are open from 8 to 5. Unfortunately, if you work during the day, you’ll have to miss time to get your tires. And while they have excellent tire pricing, you’ll pay $19.99 per tire for installation AND another $16.99 per tire for computerized balancing.

At Mavis, they perform other vehicle services as well. When you get tire work done, you shouldn’t be surprised if they try to upsell you on additional work. That’s where they make their extra money.

Bottom line

they’re good, but not as convenient as they say they are. And their installation and balancing is pricey.

Request a Quick Quote for Your Tire Services

Need a new set of winter tires on your SUV or a tire repair on your company car? We’re here for you. Are you stuck at the side of the road with a flat tire or do you simply need a tire rotation? We do that too! Contact us for a quick quote on our services or to have a mobile tire technician dispatched to you!

Get a Quote Now